News 2004 - 2006 Fogt and Messer
Update Bones found on McJunkin Rd. 8-15-05: Click Here
Appeals Trials Witnesses Messer Clan Hot News- Murders Detective Edwards News Articles Summary

So far.. Fogt has been convicted of murders in Clinton County and Highland  County.

VINCENT DOAN DOES NOT KNOW FOGT, HE KNEW "OF" HIM AND HE DID NOT HANG AROUND WITH JARROD MESSER. Carrie's Best friend's parents lived right next door to Fogt. Carrie knew Fogt & Messer.

CARRIE'S SHIRT WAS FOUND UNDER THE CONCRETE AT JARROD MESSER'S BARN IN 2004.

FOGT HAS CONFESSED TO TWO MURDERS, ONE MURDER WAS IN BLANCHESTER OH.
Fogt lived at 124 McJunkin Road Blanchester Oh. from 1994-1998, approx 3/4 of a mile from Jarrod Messer...where the dig for Carrie Culberson in the spring of 2004 produced a shirt that Carrie's family identified as Carries.  Click here for Map
VINCENT DOAN DOES NOT HAVE ANY TIES TO FOGT OR THE POLE BARN.

FOGT PRIORS:
Address:
124 McJunkin Road
City/State/ZIP: Blanchester, Oh 45107-
1st Degree Felony
Violation Date: 11/22/1994
Violation Description: Rape
----------
Violation Date: 06/08/1998
Violation Description: Felonious Assault
Degree: 2nd Degree Felony
$50,000 CASH/SURETY BOND. DEFT TO ADVISE COURT OF ADDRESS CHANGE AND HAVE NO CONTACT WITH ALLEGED VICTIM JARROD MESSER WHILE CASE IS PENDING Click here for Document.

MARCH 16, 2005- Fogt does have ties to the property in which the two week excavation occurred last Spring where items were found belonging to Carrie underneath a pole barn on Fayetteville-Blanchester, Road.
POLICE REPORTED-The Concrete floor at the pole Barn on Fayetteville-Blanchester, Road. WAS POURED JUST DAYS AFTER Carrie disappeared.
The body of Cynthia Pickens, who was 39 when she disappeared in November 2003, was found 03-15-05 buried under a steel outbuilding in Liberty Township, about a mile east of Hillsboro. A tip led officers to the building, where they found that a portion of the concrete floor had been cut out and filled to floor-level with gravel. When authorities began digging where the concrete had been cut out, they found a makeshift grave with Pickens' body buried about 2 feet from the surface.

The remains of a homicide victim discovered 03-17-05 in Hillsboro have been identified as Martha Behymer, who was also known as Martha Perry. She was 32 years old when she was killed in 1998. Investigators began search after talking with Michael Fogt, who is charged with the murder of Cynthia Pickens, 39, his former girlfriend. The Highland County Sheriff says Behymer is the mother of Fogt's 14 year old daughter. She is in the custody of Fogt's parents. The 55 gallon barrel containing Behymer's remains was found under the driveway of Fogt's parents home.


Shane Neuhaus

Suspect Charged In Another Missing Person Case
Shane Neuhaus,
a former employee of Fogt's. After digging up two bodies last week, the sheriff's office has filed charges in connection with a third missing person case in Highlands County.

Shawn Deardoff was charged over the weekend with assaulting Shane Neuhaus, who disappeared in 2003. Neuhaus' father told News 5 Friday that he thought his son "probably" was killed by the same man suspected in the two killings uncovered last week.

 

 
May 1, 2004-  Jarrod Messer lived on the Brown County property before being arrested on drug charges. The property is owned by Messer's mother, Jeanette G. Spangler, who is taking care of Messer's son while Messer is in prison.

Ron Spangler, Messer's stepfather, said Friday that Messer suspects a former associate made a claim to police that Culberson's body was buried on the property. Messer had called his mother Friday morning from prison, Spangler said.

"He said there ain't nothing there. Let 'em dig," Spangler said from his Goshen home Friday. "He said it was probably a couple of them people he was messing with when he got into that drug trouble. He's been in jail for a couple years and probably won't get out for a couple more years."

Spangler said he does not know whether Messer and Doan were friends. Debbie Culberson said she had met Messer, but did not think he had a relationship with her daughter.

 (See the dig FOR CARRIE CULBERSON at Jarrod Messer's)

APRIL 30TH 2004- Carrie's mother, Debbie Culberson, said rumors of her body being buried under the concrete have been circulating for years. She said she is not sure what information led authorities to the Brown County property.

Appeals Trials Witnesses Messer Clan Hot News- Murders Detective Edwards News Articles Summary
Home